'Solely Murders within the Constructing' Season 3: Who’s Ben speaking to in that video?

Thriller is afoot. The plot is thickening. And Solely Murders within the Constructing Season 3 already has us on the sting of our seats. 

We’re all questioning, who killed Ben (Paul Rudd)? The primary two episodes of Season 3 have already blessed us with some clues, together with a suspect listing straight out of Cluedo, nonetheless, this week’s episode gave us some extra concrete proof. We now know that Ben was preventing with somebody in his dressing room on Demise Rattle‘s opening night time. However who?

The reply is just too scrumptious.

Let’s dig into Ben’s dressing room combat.

Documentarian Tobert (Jesse Williams) is taking pictures a movie about Ben’s huge Broadway debut, and on Demise Rattle‘s opening night time, he leaves his digital camera in Ben’s dressing room the place the tape retains rolling, capturing some candid happenings within the course of. Later, as Tobert and Mabel (Selena Gomez) watch the footage, we hear Ben argue with a mysterious entity offscreen.

At first, it looks like a regular lover’s quarrel with Ben saying, “You are not purported to be right here.” However because the tape performs, it step by step looks like Ben is not truly speaking to an individual per se — however to a pile of cookies as a substitute. Hear me out. 

Throughout the desk learn in episode 1, Ben reacts dramatically after recognizing a plate of Schmackary’s cookies sitting innocently close to his chair (they even sound scrumptious). Rudd proceeds to brilliantly ship the utmost line of defeat: “There’s cookies right here.”

Dickie Glenroy (Jeremy Shamos), Ben’s brother, shortly explains to the forged that Ben’s on a strict weight-reduction plan for his subsequent CoBro film — and cookies “are a weak point.” Ben illustrates the facility of temptation that cookies have over him when he later interrupts your entire desk studying to unsubtly sneak a chew. Later within the episode, throughout Ben’s apology tour on the afterparty, Ben reveals he is solely allowed mangoes as a candy deal with. So, it is completely crucial that no cookies be round ever, lest the CoBro star alter his action-figure physique.

Here is the place the cookie concept will get chewy.

Was Ben speaking to cookies?

Credit score: Patrick Harbron/Hulu

In Tobert’s footage, Ben begins saying different issues like, “You are simply gonna sit there, performing all candy.” You recognize what’s candy? Cookies. You recognize what simply sits there tempting you with its sweetness? Cookies.

Ben’s tirade continues with a slew of phrases that might be double entendres like “We each know you are dangerous” and “I would like you so fucking dangerous, however you are gonna destroy my profession… And I am gonna like it.”

Cookies will destroy Ben’s weight-reduction plan. Cookies will presumably impact Ben’s CoBro ripped bod (and thus, if we’re being actual about unrealistic magnificence requirements completely prevalent in motion motion pictures, his profession). Cookies are what Ben needs however is aware of he cannot have. Cookies (!!!) are the factor Ben’s yelling at in Tobert’s footage.

Moreover, Ben says all the above with so a lot dramatic aptitude that it looks like a dialog he is having alone with himself in his dressing room, that nobody would ever hear. The whole silence within the clip additionally hints that nobody else was truly there with him within the room. Certainly if Ben was arguing with an individual, we might hear them retort, crying or making any sort of sound. However there’s completely nothing, simply the deafening silence from a pile of scrumptious cookies ready — demanding even — to be eaten. 

This cookie concept lends credence to an early concept of Mabel’s, which is that Ben was poisoned on opening night time. You recognize the place you may sneak in some poison? COOKIES.

Contemplating {that a} liverwurst and marmalade sandwich was final season’s killer-identifying clue, it is extremely doubtless that cookies could also be one other huge clue this season. Solely Murders within the Constructing loves a wacky plot twist, so Ben yelling at a plate of cookies in his room is completely a foolish twist that will be on model for Solely Murders Within the Constructing.

Whereas episode 3 ends with all eyes turning to Kimber (Ashley Park), Ben’s potential secret love curiosity, she might be a pink herring, distracting us from Ben’s actual — and self-confessed — love, cookies. Beware the Schmackary’s Ben, they’re out to get you. 

Learn how to watch: Season 3 of Solely Murders within the Constructing is now streaming on Hulu.